Committee wants to update Halifax crosswalk rules

Councillor says new policy would help with pedestrian safety in HRM

A Halifax council committee wants staff to look at changing the way new crosswalks are painted on city streets.

The transportation standing committee passed a motion on Thursday asking staff to take into account several new factors when determining the location of safe crossings.

HRM’s traffic authority would have to consider projected crossing demand, pedestrian compliance and crash history. It would also recognize “the practice of discouraging pedestrian crossings by leaving uncontrolled crossings unmarked is not a valid safety measure” when placing crosswalks.

The motion, which was put forwarded by Coun. Shawn Cleary, would move beyond pedestrian counts, reassess existing crosswalks, and prioritize areas close to schools, walking routes, and parks and trails.

The traffic authority is in charge of signs, sidewalks, crosswalks, and anything used to manage traffic across the region. It is authorized by the province’s Motor Vehicle Act and mostly works outside the municipal political process.

Under the Motor Vehicle Act, the province refers to the Transportation Association of Canada guidelines, which suggests approximately 15 pedestrians need to cross every hour over a seven-hour period to warrant a crosswalk.

“What we’re looking to do is see if those rules can be updated to address some of the challenges we have faced,” Coun. Paul Russell said in an interview.

Russell, the representative for District 15, said the pedestrian counts don’t capture the entire need for marked crosswalks on many busy and unsafe streets in HRM.

Pedestrian safety

Nearly 60 pedestrians have been hit by vehicles in HRM this year, says Halifax Regional Police. Two people died after being struck be a vehicle, two people were seriously injured, and 17 moderately injured.

Those numbers are down from last year. At the same point in 2019, 105 pedestrians had been hit by vehicles, three people were killed, five seriously injured, and 24 moderately injured.

Norm Collins, president of the Crosswalk Safety Society of Nova Scotia, doesn’t think the streets are getting safer. He believes the numbers are down because COVID-19 has resulted in less traffic.

Collins said HRM would be taking a step in the right direction with this motion, especially if HRM realized that discouraging pedestrian crossings by leaving uncontrolled crossings unmarked is not a valid safety measure.

More still needs to be done to improve pedestrian safety, he said, and it requires a combination of solutions. He believes it needs to involve pedestrians, drivers, police enforcement, and traffic engineering.

“We don’t even have the guts to ban right hand turns at red lights,” he said in an interview Friday.

Russell agrees the crosswalk motion is only going to fix part of the overall problem. He said Halifax also needs to look at improving sidewalks to keep pedestrians safe.

“One solution won’t fit all,” Russell said.

Collins, who helped install almost 200 crosswalk flags across HRM, still feels the city can do more. He points to Oslo in Norway, a city that is twice the size of Halifax but had zero pedestrian and cyclist fatalities in 2019.

“Halifax traffic is a follower, not a leader,” Collins said.

Have a story idea? Let us know


  1. Why not give tickets to those who cross on red lights right in front of a car coming down on a green light, I see it every day downtown.

  2. Leaving uncontrolled pedestrian crossings unmarked makes as much sense as not doing anything to enforce the 30 km/hr speed limit in school zones.

  3. It’s really the City’s fault. As a driver, I can never understand why I get a green light when I’m turning, and people can cross the road. It’s so annoying. Why doesn’t the city do it like Quebec City… All crosswalks are diagonal like an X and all traffic is stopped. Pedestrians have the rightaway, and no cars move…duh

  4. Drivers are in a rush and do not pay attention to walkers during this pandemic. They are putting a new crosswalk at corner of Braeside Lane and Lacewood. The workers could not believe how fast the traffic goes on that Street.

  5. As a driver I would love an education campaign about the rules that people seem to ignore, every intersection that is unmarked in a residential neighborhood you yield to pedestrian traffic, you don’t honk them off the road for impeding your “right of way” that you don’t own!

  6. Perhaps the city need to revisit and update its policy about the assumed rights of pedestrians to assume every corner is a crosswalk, even where there is no stop sign. The requirement that drivers stop where there are no stop signs because it is a street corner makes no sense, it creates dangerous situations for both cars and pedestrians. Also when pedestrians use or abuse this understanding to cross at the corner where there is no crosswalk when one is just across the street at the adjacent corner, and expect the same protection as a crosswalk. Same thing, confusing and dangerous.
    I’m a driver and a pedestrian, and both need to respect the other. However, no matter if a pedestrian has a “right” to be in the roadway, they need to be fully aware that they are responsible for their own safety, look around, be intentional, be present, be sure you have the attention of the drivers on the road. Better to be safe, than dead right.

  7. Not stopping at a red light before turning right is a big problem. Some don’t even slow down. I was about to cross on a walk signal this week in Bayers Lake when a van came up to the red light at excessive speed obviously planning on a right turn (there was no traffic coming from the left) and he hit the brakes quickly when he saw me waiting to cross. He was obviously looking left for traffic and didn’t see me on the right. I cross that intersection regularly to get to the bus stop on the other side and always have to wait for vehicles to stop as they aren’t paying attention to pedestrians. On the other hand to be fair some do see me and stop and then realize that I can’t cross yet because the walk light isn’t on (it comes on after the left turn arrow goes off.)

  8. T The problem I see is that there is little traffic enforcement on the peninsula. There is regular speeding, running of red lights, right hand turns without stopping and in general aggressive driving. I have never seen traffic enforcement in my area.

  9. I believe we need cross walk improvement as well as addressing the Yield Sign purpose.

    Today, drivers are not following the rules regarding Yield Signs especially coming off ramps or merging into on coming traffic.

    We did a great job with the new parking meters so now let’s invest in Traffic Cameras for driving infractions and rule breaking. This will also improve safety for Crosswalks as well.

Comments are closed.