Auditor general report finds gaps in environmental assessments
Provincial government has backtracked on five of seven prior recommendations, 'muzzled' government reviewers
caption
Auditor general Kim Adair speaks at a press conference following the publishing of a report on the efficacy of Nova Scotia's environmental assessment process.A new report on environmental assessments from Nova Scotia’s attorney general says the government is no longer in compliance with five of seven recommendations made by the auditor general in a 2017 report.
The other two recommendations were found to have key implementation gaps.
The auditor general’s report, released on Tuesday, says there are gaps in transparency on how environmental assessments are completed, whether expert findings and suggestions are met or even considered, and how report findings are presented for ministerial approval.
According to auditor general Kim Adair, “Information (regarding environmental assessments) is not always provided to the minister through briefing materials and decision advice . . . the current process relies largely on self-reported information by the project owner.”
She says due to this, Nova Scotians are only offered “limited assurance of compliance on projects.”
Adair’s investigation found “limited involvement from subject matter experts,” and “no assessment in whether terms and conditions were actually effective in reducing environmental impacts.”
She says her office found that government reviewers felt “muzzled,” and were directed not to include their findings on environmental impact, or to “alter or soften” their comments.
In a study of nine wind power projects, Adair’s office found that developers needed only to submit required documents, with no expectation to demonstrate compliance with environmental regulations.
At a news conference last week, Environment and Climate Change Minister Tim Halman said he is “confident in the current regulatory framework that we have.”
At the auditor general’s press conference on Tuesday, MLA Lisa Lachance said the findings are “deeply concerning,” and Lachance doesn’t “trust this process . . . Nova Scotians can’t trust the environmental assessment that’s supposed to protect them,” they said.
Lachance said they have little confidence that the government will follow through on its commitment to implement the recommendations, as “they have let the system degrade over the time they have been in power.”
Adair said the provincial government plans to implement all 13 of the auditor general’s 2026 recommendations starting in June 2027.
The report noted that Nova Scotia’s environmental assessment processes are currently consistent with other Canadian jurisdictions.
About the author
Nick Wells
Nick is a master of journalism student at King's. He is passionate about politics, sports and telling the stories of Nova Scotians through their...
Leave a Reply